Lollipop Man
Image by Paul Conneally on Flickr | Click for original

West Heath Primary School was last week granted a reprieve from the process of being forced to accept academy status started earlier this year by the Department for Education. 

In a letter sent out to parents, school governors wrote: “I am writing to inform you that last night Local Authority representatives met with the Governing Body to inform them that due to the school’s two years of improved SATs results and satisfactory OfSTED, the Department for Education has decided not to continue the Forced Academy Agenda for West Heath Primary School at this present time.”

Here, MP Richard Burden reacts to the news.

“I am so pleased that the cloud which has been hanging over West Heath School has now been lifted.

Not only was the pressure on the school to become an academy unpopular with parents. It was also irrelevant to addressing the school’s needs in the coming years. The important thing now is for everyone to focus firmly on sustaining an improving results at the school and on doing the right thing by the children of the West Heath area. That means today’s pupils and those of tomorrow .

The West Heath school story also holds important lessons for other schools too. All too often schools feel bullied into accepting conversion to an academy, irrespective of whether or not it is the right thing for the school involved. Ministers bully the DfE who in turn bully Local authorities, heads and governing bodies. Parents can end up feeling their wishes are a bit irrelevant to the process even though it is their children’s future at stake.

But West Heath parents have shown that it is possible to ask “why?” and, if necessary say “no”, even when they are told that everything is a fait accomplis. In future, it won’t be possible to stop every academy being for forced through by the Government and, in some cases, parents may even agree with conversion. But West Heath parents have shown that it is possible to stop local opinion being bulldozed and to change the course of events. There is a big lesson there for other schools.

In the coming months, the forced academy programme is not going to be the cakewalk Michael Gove wanted. It is increasingly clear that there are not necessarily enough outside sponsors around to deliver the goods for him in enough schools. And it is also becoming clear that the timescales for forced conversion being pushed over the last year are simply unrealistic in many cases.

In Birmingham there is another important change too – in the role and attitude of the City Council. Under the previous Conservative-led administration, the council seemed at best irrelevant to schools being forced down the academy route, and in some cases the council seemed to behave as if it was a wholly owned subsidiary of Whitehall. Under the new Labour Cabinet member, Brigid Jones, that is changing and the Council is actively developing a cooperative alternative to Planet Gove for schools in the City; an alternative that Ministers will have to take seriously. They need to move fast, but the refusal of Birmingham Council to simply roll over in relation to West Heath augurs well for the future.

So well done to all concerned – to the parents, to local Labour Councillors like Brett O’Reilly and Val Seabright, to local campaigners and, this time to Birmingham Council. School bullies do not have to get their way.”


  1. not all parents were unhappy about it becoming an academy, if it gives a better education for my kids i’m all for it, especially if the naughty children go (which is why some of the parents are against), at least my kids could go and not worry about been stabbed with a pencil.

  2. all evidence proves that academies do not fair any better with school results. When all the money runs out where do the schools turn to to get help? Please read all the literature there is availble on the internet and you may be in a better position to make a educated decision on the matter. The matter regarding your child being stabbed with a pencil did you speak to the parent in question? The child is not naughty. Please access the website You will be better informed to make an opinion on the matter.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.